15 Common PBL Mistakes | mistake 6: treat all kids the same
I have the best job in the world. On a regular basis, I’m given the extraordinary fortune to talk with teachers who are embarking on a PBL journey with their students. To dig into the smaller, everyday details of how to make this type of learning environment work. To answer the tough questions about sustainability, rigor, behavior management and then take the questioner further…that’s like chocolate to me! I can’t get enough.
Over the years of starting my own PBL school and learning in a baptismal fire, I’ve been able to find a way to talk with new or reluctant teachers about their concerns. Additionally, there are things that excited, energetic teachers might want to consider as they take their first steps into the PBL fire as well.
In the next month or so, I’ll be publishing a regular series to include 15 common mistakes that educators make and some solutions they might consider. Here’s the next one in the series:
Continue to treat all kids as if they’re the same and need to be treated the same.
Problem: Currently, we feel that in order to be “fair,” all students need to be treated the same, when in actuality, there are very few students who have the same ability, experiences, or skills as others in the class. Everyone is traveling their own journey many of us know nothing about and children and teens are no different.
Solution: To be truly fair, or equitable, with students, we must look at them as individuals. Each will move faster or slower, according to her abilities and interests. We might consider grouping students based not on their “date of manufacture,” but instead upon something much more appropriate. Some students might make a mistake and need one type of consequence while another student is better served through other consequences. On a broader, school-wide system, this might lead to a slippery slope to favoritism within a time-based, “everyone’s the same” school. But in a school that focuses on services and support for individual students as humans, this is a readily understood concept. But how to go about re-visioning our own environments is a challenge for local communities to solve. Many schools will choose to implement the flexibility on a classroom-level scale first before re-visioning their entire building or district. Regardless, personalized learning must trump the one-size-fits-all curriculum of today.
Want to learn more about Project/Problem Based Learning?
- Check out Edutopia’s annotated bibliography for PBL research
- The Buck Institute for Education has also collected a terrific bank of PBL research
In 2006 with 12 years of traditional classroom experience and 2 days of formal PBL training in her pocket, Ginger Lewman started a middle school, grades 5-8, that was a 1:1 laptop and Project Based Learning environment. Five years later, the middle school had doubled in population twice and had expanded to include PBL in grades K-8. They were also in the process of opening a PBL high school the next fall. Ginger now works with school leaders in helping them learn how to support the PBL shift, and inspires their teachers to take the leap. Meanwhile, she also continues to co-teach with K-12 teachers in the training process, keeping her own teaching chops sharp and ready.